Klinefelter Syndrome: Clinical Implications of Expanding Phenotype
Author(s): Rima Dada, Rakesh Kumar, M E Ahmad, Rajeev Kumar, RS Sharma, NP Gupta, A Mitra, Gupta SK, K Kucheria
Vol. 3, No. 6 (2007-01 - 2007-02)
Rima Dada, Rakesh Kumar, M E Ahmad, Rajeev Kumar, RS Sharma, NP Gupta, A Mitra, Gupta SK, K Kucheria
ISBN: 0973-516X
Rima Dada, MD, PhD (Associate Professor) and Rakesh Kumar (PhD Scholar) are from the
Department of Anatomy,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India.
M E Ahmad is PDF, CWRU, Cleveland, Ohio,USA
Rajeev Kumar is Associate Professor,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India
R S Sharma is Chief, ART Centre,
Army Research and Referral Hospital, New Delhi.
N P Gupta, M.S, M.Ch, FAMS, is Professor and Head, Department of Urology,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India.
A Mitra (Research Associate) and S K Gupta (Chief, Gamete Antigen Laboratory) are from the
National Institute of Immunology (NII), New Delhi.
K Kucheria, PhD, is Emeritus Medical Scientist,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India
Corresponding Author: Dr Rima Dada, MD, PhD (Genetics), Associate Professor,
Lab for Molecular Reproduction and Genetics, Department of Anatomy, AIIMS, New Delhi 29
Email: [email protected]
Abstract:
Chromsomal abnormalities are common in infertile men with an incidence of 5.8% as compared to
0.5% in the general population. Klinefelter syndrome is the commonest genetic cause of hypogonadism and
infertility. The incidence of sex chromosome abnormalities is 1 in 400 births which include 47,XXY; 47,XXX
and 45,X karyotypes. The addition of more than one extra X or Y chromosome occurs rarely. Many studies
consider variants as a part of Klinefelter syndrome (KFS), but these cases have additional phenotypic anomalies
and should be considered as a distinct entity. The phenotypic defect in 47,XXY is well known but in variant
cases with polysomy of X and Y leads to additional features like cardiovascular, skeletal, behavioural, language
and expressive and speech disorders. For these clinical problems therapy is available and early diagnosis and
early androgen therapy facilitates better management of these cases. There is a direct correlation between the
number of additional sex chromosome and severity of the phenotype. Therefore, in order to analyze these
variant cases in detail this study was planned.
Key words: Klinefelter syndrome (KFS), Mosaic, Variants, Hypogonadism
Introduction
Klinefelter’s syndrome is the most
common genetic cause of male infertility, yet
many cases remain undiagnosed because of
substantial variation in clinical presentation.
Early diagnosis and management with
hormonal treatment can substantially improve
the quality of life and prevent serious
consequences. Sex chromosomal
abnormalities occur in at least 1 in 400 births.
One of the commonest chromosomal
aneuploidy is Klinefelter Syndrome (KFS).
KFS is the first human sex chromosomal
abnormality to have been detected and is
characterized by gynaecomastia, euchnoidism,
small firm testes with hyalinization of seminiferous tubules, semeniferous tubular
dysgenesis, androgen deficiency,
hypergonadotrophic hypogonadism and
azoospermia. This abnormality is the
commonest cause of hypogonadsim and is
associated with male infertility and cognitive
defects. Its prevalence is 0.1% among infertile
patients, up to 11% among the azoospermic,
and 0.7% of oligozoospermics have 47,XXY
chromosome complement. Of the 125 cases of
male infertility referred to us, 44 were
clinically diagnosed cases of KFS. We
analyzed these 44 clinically suspected cases of
KFS at the cytogenetic and molecular level
using Fluorescent In situ Hybridisation (FISH)
and found 14 cases with 47,XXY chromosome
complement (KFS) and 23 cases with
46,XY/47,XXY karyotype. These cases were
Klinefelter mosaics (KFM). Seven cases,
which had additional cell lines, were classified
as mosaic variants (KFV). These variant-cases
showed additional clinical features, therefore
they were studied in detail and their genotype
was correlated with the phenotype.
Material and methods
Of the 125 cases of male infertility,
44 were clinically suspected cases of
Klinefelter Syndrome and were referred to the
infertility clinic of Urology and Endocrinology
at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences.
In each case a detailed clinical, reproductive
and family history was taken and FSH, LH and
testosterone levels were collected. Semen
analysis was performed for assessing semen
volume, pH, sperm count, viability,
morphology, and motility as per the WHO
guidelines (1999) (1). Testicular Fine Needle
peripheral blood culture. Twenty-five well
spread G-banded metaphases were karyotyped
using Image Analysis System (Cytovision;
Applied Imaging). In mosaic cases, 50 wellspread
metaphases were analyzed. Fluorescent
Aspiration Cytology (FNAC) was done
whenever possible. Cytogenetic analysis was
performed in each case by setting up In Situ
Hybridization (FISH) was done following the
standard protocol in 23 mosaic and 7 variant
cases to identify any cryptic or low level
mosaicism not detected cytogenetically. For
FISH analysis, 200 interphase cells and 25
metaphase spreads were scored and the authors
used CEP X and CEP Y fluorescent labeled
probes. In the present paper, we discuss these
cases with special emphasis on variant KF
cases.
Klinefelter Syndrome
Of the 125 cases analysed
cytogenetically 44 cases had KFS, of whom 14
had 47,XXY chromosome complement or
were mosaics 46,XY/47,XXY-KFM (n=23) or
variants KFV (n=7). The details of variant
cases and comparison of KFV cases with the
mosaic KFM and KFS cases have been
tabulated (Tables 1 and 2).
Cases with 47,XXY Karyotype (KFS)
There were 14 cases with 47,XXY
chromosomal complement, the mean age of
whom was 25.6 years (range 20-35 years) and
median height 170cm (range 158-188cm).
Twelve cases had hypogonadism, two cases
cryptorchidism and one case unilateral
varicocele. Three of the 14 cases had
micropenis while the rest had a normal
phallus. Twelve cases exhibited poor
development of secondary sexual characters;
only two cases had well developed secondary
sexual characters. Four cases had
gynaecomastia. Seven cases had female
habitus, while the other 7 had normal male
habitus and were tall and thin. Of the 14
cases, 6 were mentally retarded while 8 cases
had a normal intelligence quotient (IQ). Five
cases showed behavioural abnormalities with
severe temper tantrums and violent outbursts.
Three cases had speech abnormalities with
difficulty in expressed speech. One case was
impotent. All the fourteen cases were
azoospermic (ie had complete absence of
sperms in the semen). Thirteen cases had
raised FSH levels while 1 case had decreased
FSH level. In all the cases testosterone levels
were low. Nine men were tall (>5 ft 8inch)
and thin. Diabetes mellitus, anaemia and
hepatitis B were found in 2 cases, one case had
history of epileptic fits, while one case had
asthma and recurrent episodes of upper
respiratory infection. Testicular FNAC was
done in 5 cases and showed ‘Sertoli Cell Only’
Type I syndrome (SCO Type I); in one case testicular biopsy showed hyalinization of the
seminiferous tubules.
Table 1. Phenotypic Features in Men Mosaic Variants
Case No
Karyotype
Phenotype
FSH mIU/ml
LH mIU/ml
T (ng/ml)
Case 1
47,XXY/
48,XXXXY/
49,XXXYY
SCO, BL Small, biopsy cluster of leydig cells only. MVP, sm penis, fat, hair on body present M19, P21, MR
3.75
12
0.4
Case 2
46,XY(50%)/
47,XXY/
48,XXYY (20%)
BL Small, Gyn Gr 3,Brest cancer small penis, no sec sex, low post. hair line, 5.8ft, M28, P30, speech abn, MR
24
36
2.8
Case 3
46,XY(53%)/
48,XXXY/
49,XXXYY
Thick BM, hyaline of ST (Biopsy), BL small testes, small penis, poor sec. sex, ASD, hypotonia, MR, no schooling d/t poor adj, temper, Speech abnormality, M33, P34
24
45
0.46
Case 4
47,XXY/
48,XXYY/
46,XX(20%)/
47,XYY/
50, XXXXYY
Sm, Tall 6.2, obese, Coxavalga, Gyn, low post. hair line, broad nasal bridge, coarse facial features
56.8
60
ND
Case 5
47,XXY (91%)/
48,XXXY (3%)/
48,XXYY (3%)/
46,XY (3%)
Hypogonadism, Atrophic, Prim. testicular failure, LoD, IQ less, poor in studies, MR, Gyn speech abn, 6 ft, M24,F30, micropenis, No sec sex
56
68
0.2
Case 6
47,XXY/
48,XXYY/
46,XY(24%)
Hypogonadism. Poor development of secondary sexual characters, very tall, small penis, speech abnormal,,Pulmonary stenosis
44
38
0.4
Case 7
47,XXY/
48,XXYY/
48,XXXY
Hypogonadism, poor dev. of seconadary sexual characters, slurred speech, congenital dislocation of hip, coarse facial features
32
40
0.2
Key: T3, T4, TSH: Thyroid hormones; ST: Seminiferous tubules; Dev: Development; d/t: due to; LoD: Lack of development; Gyn:
Gynaecomastia; SSC: Secondary sexual characters; Sm: Small gonads; M: Maternal age; P: Paternal age; B/L: Bilateral; Lt: Left; Rt:
Right; MR: Mental retardation; Crypt: Cryptorchidism; ND: Not detected; Abn: Abnormal; Adj: Adjustment; URI: Upper respiratory
tract infection; Desc: Descended; IQ: Intelligence Quotient; DM: Diabetes mellitus; Temp exp: Temperature exposure; H/o: History
of; Prim: Primary; Hyalin: Hyalinization of seminiferous tubules
Table 2. Distribution of Clinical Abnormalities in KFS, Mosaic KF and Mosaic Variants Cases
S. No.
Features
KFS n-14
KFM n-23
KFV n-7
1
Hypogonadism
12
17
6
2
Cryptorchidism
2
5
0
3
FNAC/ Biopsy-SCOI*/Hypospermatogenesis#
5*
1#
2*
4
Poor development of secondary sexual characters
12
12
6
5
Small penis
3
2
4
6
Impotent
1
0
0
7
Female habitus
7
1
0
8
Gynaecomastia
4
4
3
9
ALL/Radiotherapy
1
0
0
10
Mental Retardation/Poor in studies
6
1
4
11
Temper tantrums/Violent behaviour
5
1
1
12
Azoospermic
14
20
7
13
Oligozoospermic/ OAT
0
3
0
14
Congenital heart disease (CHD)
0
0
3
15
Delayed milestones
0
1
0
16
Low posterior hair line
0
0
2
17
Speech abnormality
3
0
5
18
Varicocele
1
0
0
19
Recurrent URI
1
1
0
20
Very Tall ≥5-8
9
12
6
21
Epileptic Fits
1
0
0
22
DM/Anaemia/Hepatitis B
2
1
0
23
High Temperature Exposure
0
2
0
24
Hypotonia
0
0
1
25
Skeletal abnormality
0
0
2
26
Normal FSH (1.2-5mIU/ml)
0
1
1
27
FSH raised
13
21
6
28
FSH low
1
0
0
29
Testosterone (2.7 –10.7ng/ml)
0
0
1
30
Testosterone low
13
22
6
Mosaic Klinefelter Cases (KFM)
(46,XY/47,XXY)
There were 23 mosaic cases of
Klinefelter syndrome with a mean age of 25.5
years. Seventeen cases presented with
hypogonadism and 5 cases had
cryptorchidism. Eleven cases had well
developed and 12 cases poorly developed
secondary sexual characters. Twelve patients
were tall (height > 5’8”). Of the 23 cases, only
four cases had gynaecomastia. Two cases had
micropenis; in the vast majority (21) of the
cases the phallus size was normal. One case
had mental retardation and was poor at studies;
he was violent at times with frequent
adjustment problem with his peers. Twenty
mosaic Klinefelter cases were azoospermic
with no sperms in the semen and 3 were
oligozoospermic. Of the latter, two had a high
percentage of morphologically abnormal
sperms with impaired motility and were oligoastheno-
teratozoospermic (OAT). These cases
had, respectively, 90%, 75% and 70% normal
cell line. One case was a diabetic. Two cases
had occupational exposure to high
temperature; one of them was azoospermic and
one had OAT. Twenty one cases had raised
FSH levels, while two cases had FSH in the
normal range. Decreased testosterone levels
were detected in all the twenty three cases.
Testicular FNAC was available in one case
with 46,XY(90%)/47,XXY chromosome
complement and showed
hypospermatogenesis.
Variant Klinefelter
There were 7 mosaic variant
Klinefelter cases with a mean age of 30.4
years. Six of them presented with
hypogonadism and six had poor development
of secondary sexual characters. Four cases had
micropenis while the phallus was of normal
size in three cases. All the 7 cases were
azoospermic. The FSH levels were raised in 6
cases but within normal limits in 1 case. The
testosterone levels too were low in 6 cases and
in the normal range in one patient. Six of the 7
cases were tall (>5 ft 8 in). Two cases had a
low posterior hair line. Three cases had
gynaecomastia (figure 1) and one case was
diagnosed with breast cancer. Of the 7 cases, 3
had, respectively, congenital heart disease with
mitral valve prolapse (MVP), atrial septal
defect (ASD) and pulmonary stenosis with
pulmonary hypertension. One of the seven
cases had coxa vara and thus difficulty in
walking and one case had congenital
dislocation of the hip (CDH) at birth. FNAC
biopsy showed ‘Sertoli Cell Only’ Type 1
(SCO type I) Syndrome in one case and the
presence of Sertoli cells and clumps of Leydig
cells in one. Details of all the KFV (Klinefelter
variants) cases are given in Table1.
DISCUSSION
In the present study there were a total
of 44 cases of Klinefelter syndrome, of whom
14 had 47,XXY chromosomal pattern (KFS),
23 were mosaic Klinefelter (KFM)
(47,XXY/46,XY) and 7 were mosaic variants.
All these cases were analysed at cytogenetic
and molecular cytogenetic level using FISH.
FISH confirmed the presence and proportion
of mosaic cell lines and also identified cell
lines not detected by routine cytogenetic
methods. This cell line was detected in
interphase cells and thus helps in a better
understanding of the phenotype and
correlations with the genotype. Okada et al.,
(1999)(2) studied 148 patients with sterility
caused by Klinefelter Syndrome and found
140 men with Klinefelter Syndrome and 8 men
to be mosaic Klinefelter. The overall
percentage of Klinefelter cases in the present
study was 35.2% (44/125). This was much
higher than that previously reported (3%)(3).
This higher prevalence may be due to the fact
that AIIMS is a national-level tertiary referral
hospital and therefore a high number of
suspected KFS cases are referred to us for
cytogenetic and molecular analysis. KFS is a
leading genetic cause of male infertility. In the
present study prevalence of KFS among
azoospermic cases was 24.10%. This was
higher than 11% reported by Nemeth et al,
(2002)(4) but was consistent with the findings
of Tournaye et al.,(1996) (5) who reported an
incidence of 15-22% in azoospermic men.
Okada et al (1999) reported a prevalence of
70.4% in azoospermics and De Braekleer and
Dao in (1991)(6) a value of 10%. We found an
incidence of 12.5% KFS among the
oligozoospermic cases, which is much higher
than that reported earlier (0.7%) by Nemeth et
al, (2002)(4). This high percentage may be explained by the small number of cases
oligozoospermia in our study. Although
gynaecomastia has been reported previously in
50% of patients (Tournaye et al., 1996) (5) it
was found in only 25% of our cases. One case
with gynaecomastia had breast cancer. The
incidence of breast cancer is increased by 50%
in men with KFS. Median height and weight
indicated that the patients were slightly taller
and thinner than the average cytogenetically
normal men of the same age. These findings
are similar to those of Okada et al (1999) (2).
Over 80% of our patients had small testes, 7
men had cryptorchidism of which 5 were
mosaics (46,XY/47,XXY). Saragawa et al
(1992) (7) reported an association between KFS
and hypospadias and cryptorchidism. In the
present study none of the KFS or KFM cases
had hypospadias but seven cases had
cryptorchidism. Nine cases had normal testis
and 35 cases (79.8%) had small testis. These
findings are slightly lower than those reported
by Tournaye etal.,(1996) (5) , who reported
small testes in 95% of the affected men. The
mean age of the Klinefelter patients was 27.1
years in the present study which was lower
than 32 years found by Okada et al (2). This
may be because of an early age at marriage in
India as compared to that in Japan as a result
of which the cases report with infertility at an
earlier age in India.
Semen analysis revealed azoospermia
in all the 14 cases of KFS, 20 cases of mosaic
Klinefelter and 7 mosaic variants. Three
mosaic cases with 30%, 15% and 10%
47,XXY cell line showed oligozoospermia.
One of the mosaic cases worked in a rubber
preparation factory and was exposed to high
temperature which might have led to a high
percentage of sperms with morphological
abnormalities and impaired motility.(8)
Testicular fine needle aspiration cytology
(FNAC) showed hypospermatogenesis in this
case. Though KFS is associated with a
testicular phenotype of hyalinization of
seminiferous tubules and semeniferous tubular
dysgenesis this case showed
hypospermatogenesis. This may be due to the
presence of 90% normal cell line, 46,XY.
Though KFS is associated with azoospermia,
recent studies (5,9) have reported
spermatogenesis in mosaic cases. Two cases
showed OAT though one of them had no
exposure to high temperature. Okada et al.,
(1999) (2) also reported a high percentage of
sperms with morphological abnormalities
especially round and elongated spermatids in
KFS subjects. In the present study, there were
majority of sperms with amorphous head
(22%), coiled tail (38%), and tapered head
(15%).
Pubic hair distribution and euchnoid
habitus was seen in 8 of the 44 cases. Okada et
al (1999) (2) reported euchnoid habitus and
female pattern of hair distribution in one third
of the studied cases. Half of the patients in
their study had low testosterone concentrations
with elevated gonadotrophins while 50% had
normal concentrations of testosterone. In the
present study, however, we found low
testosterone levels in the majority (93.2%) of
cases; normal testosterone level was found
only in one case. Of the 44 cases,
gonadotrophins (FSH and LH) were elevated
in 40 (90.9%) of cases, low in one case and
within the normal range in three cases.
Two mosaic variants had low posterior
hair line which has not been reported earlier in
KF cases. The percentage of mosaicism
detected by G banding and FISH was almost
identical after scoring 200 interphase cells and
25 metaphase spreads. In one case FISH
detected an additional cell line of
50,XXXXYY which was not detected
cytogenetically. Thus FISH helps in detection
of cryptic and low level mosaicism and is an
important adjunct to conventional
cytogenetics. FISH is a highly sensitive,
efficient, accurate and reproducible technique
that can be used independently for screening
of aneuploidies. (10,11)
Azoospermia is not a consistent
feature of KFS. Beregere et al in 2002 (9)
found that 47,XXY subjects showed germinal
aplasia while 46,XY/47,XXY mosaics focally
showed spermatogenesis but Tournaye et al
(1996) (5) found foci of spermatogenesis in
some 47,XXY cases. Four out of 8 47,XXY
subjects showing spermatogenesis were
reported by Bergere et al (2002)(9). In the
present study, 3 mosaic cases had
oligoasthenoteratozoospermia and 1 case
showed hypospermatogenesis. But two cases
had high percentage (64% and 83%) of sperms
with abnormal morphology and impaired
motility and one case had oligozoospermia.
Sparkes et al., (1973) (12) and Foresta et al.,
(1999) (13) also reported a number of cases of
KFS who had succeeded in fathering a child
before the era of Assisted Reproduction. One
case with 47,XXY chromosome complement
had acute lymphocytic leukemia (ALL).
Patients with KFS are known to be at an
increased risk of malignant tumours(14) . Three
variant mosaic cases, respectively, had
congenital heart disease with mitral valve
prolapse (MVP), atrial septal defect (ASD)
and pulmonary stenosis with pulmonary
arterial hypertension. Congenital heart defects
have been reported in mosaic variant
Klinefelter cases in earlier studies (15). These
cardiovascular anomalies were not observed in
KFS or KFM cases but three Klinefelter
variants had cardiovascular anomalies. The
presence of 48,XXYY and 49,XXXYY cell
line probably led to the development of this
cardiovascular defect. Studies have found that
the greater the aneuploidy the more severe is
the clinical manifestation of the disorder (16) .
One KFS case had a history of epileptic fits
since birth. Earlier tonic clonic seizures and
epileptiform electroencephalograms (EEGs)
were reported in 12 cases of KFS (16).
Neurological deficit and seizures have also
been reported by Tournaye etal.,(1996) (5) in
KFS cases.
Twenty five percent (11/44) cases
were found to have a low IQ in the present
study, 17% also had behavioural problems and
had violent temper outbursts. A higher risk of
learning disabilities, cognitive deficit, and
behavioural and psychiatric disorders exist in
KFS, mosaics and mosaic variants. Linden et
al., (1995) (17) and Kruse et al.,(1998) (18)
reported that mental capability diminishes
directly with the number of extra X
chromosomes and IQ reduction of 15 to 16
points occurs with addition of each extra X
chromosome.
One case with KFS and 3 variant
mosaics had slurred speech and difficulty in
expressive language. Linden et al., (1995) (17)
concluded that language is also directly
affected by the number of extra X
chromosomes. Expressive and receptive
language are both severely affected in men
with extra X chromosome and this may lead to
violent temper outbursts (16,17) .
One variant mosaic was found to have
hypotonia. Low muscle tone and muscular
incoordination has been previously reported by
Linden et al.,(1995) (17) who found that
coordination is affected by extra genetic
material. One mosaic variant case had coxa
valga since birth and another variant case had
congenital dislocation of hip (CDH). Skeletal
anomalies like radioulnar synostosis, coxa
valga and vara have been reported previously
in KFV (15,17).
In addition there were 2 cases, one
KFM and one KFS case with diabetes
mellitus and one case with hepatitis B also
had KFS. Two cases, one KFM and one
KFS, had recurrent episodes of upper
respiratory tract infection and asthma.
Takeuchi et al., (1999) (19) reported a case of
KFS with mixed connective tissue disease and
diabetes mellitus. Mulliez et al., (1986) (20)
reported respiratory disorders in 47,XXY
subjects.
The pentasomy (49,XXXYY) and
tetrasomy (48,XXYY) are two of the rarest
sex chromosome defects occurring with an
estimated incidence of 1 in 85,000 and 1 in
50,000 male births respectively.(21) In the
curent study we had 7 variant cases and these
cases had additional phenotypic features,
cardiovascular and skeletal abnormalities, and
severe mental retardation. Sex chromosomal
polysomy is associated with pre- and postnatal
growth deficiency, severe mental
retardation, hypogenitalism, and skeletal,
facial and cardiovascular anomalies. Linden et
al (1995) (17) suggested that polysomy X and Y
may lead to cognitive and behavioural
problems which, in turn, might affect somatic
development. The addition of a single X to an
XY karyotype results in semeniferous tubule
dysgenesis. Additional X and Y chromosome
result not only in infertility but also in
hypoplastic and malformed external genitalia.
Three mosaic KF cases in our study had
oligozoospermia. The presence of germ cells
could probably be because of the normal cell
line being the major cell line in these cases.
Estop et al ( 1998)(22) and Foresta et al
(1999)(13) suggested that in mosiac KF cases,
germ cells may achieve meiosis and may
produce mature spermatozoa. Accordingly,
such cases from our study were made aware of
the Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART)
and were counselled to go in for case they opted for ART. All the variant cases
had strikingly elevated gonadotrophins
indicating markedly severe testicular damage
due to the presence of extra genetic material
and all were azoopsermic.
One of the cases (Case 2) presented
with marked gynaecomastia. KF cases with
gynaecomastia have been reported to have an
increased risk of breast cancer (23).
One KFV case (Case 3) had a
relatively milder phenotype with no
cardiovascular or skeletal abnormality. The
lesser severity of manifestation could be due to
the presence of normal cell line compared to a
male with pure polysomy X or Y and
relatively few clinical manifestation. But the
patient had an aggressive disposition with a
low IQ. Abnormal behaviours and temper
tantrums have been reported in sex
chromosomal aneuploides in early studies (17).
A direct correlation between testicular
function and FSH level is well established(24).
The increase in FSH levels is a reliable
indicator of testicular damage. However
testicular FNAC of Case 1 showed Sertoli Cell
Only Syndrome Type I indicating severe
testicular damage although FSH and LH levels
were within the normal range. The present
finding stresses on the need of FNAC in such
cases.
The present study highlights
substantial variability in variant cases due to
genetic heterogeneity. Molecular cytogenetic
analysis also aids in a better understanding of
the genotype-phenotype correlation by
identifying cell lines not identified
cytogenetically. Generalization of these
mosaic cases is not possible and they should
not be confused with classical KFS cases with
47,XXY karyotype. Detailed clinical, genetic
evaluation should be undertaken and genetic
counseling offered with early treatment to get
better results by androgen therapy and
psychological help.
Our study suggests that a larger
number of cases needs to be analysed at both
cytogenetic and molecular level to be able to
appreciate the variability of phenotype and its
correlations with the genotype. That will
facilitate provision of suitable genetic
counseling, early treatment, and better
management of such cases.
Acknowledgements:
Authors thank the Indian
Council of Medical Research (ICMR) for
the financial support.
REFERENCES
- World Health Organization. Laboratory
Manual for the Examination of Human
Semen and Sperm Cervical Mucus
Interaction. 3rd edition. Cambridge
University Press, Melbourne, Australia
1999.
- Okado H, Fujioka H, Tatsumi N, Kanzaki
M, Okuda Y, Fujisawa M, Hazama M,
Matsumoto O, Gohji K, Arakawa S,
Kamidono S. Klinefelter’s syndrome in
the male infertility clinic. Human
Reprod 1999; 14 (4): 946-952
- Van Assche E, Bonduelle M, Tournaye H,
Joris H, Verheyen G, Devroey P, Van
Steirteghem. Cytogenetics of infertile men.
Hum Reprod 1996; 11 (4): 1-24.
- Nemeth AH, Gallen IW, Crocker M, Levy
E, Maher E. Klinefelter-like phenotype
and primary infertility in a male with a
paracentric Xq inversion. J Med Genetics
2002; 39(6): 28.
- Tournaye H, Staessen C, Liebars I, Van
Assche E, Devroey P, Bonduelle M, Van
Steirteghem A. Testicular sperm recovery
in nine 47, XXY Klinefelter patients. Hum
Reprod 1996;11: 1644-49.
- De Braekeleer M, Dao TN. Cytogenetic
studies in male infertility: a review. Hum
Reprod 1991; 6(2): 245-250.
- Sasagawa I, Nakada T, Hashimoto T,
Ishigooka M, adachi Y, Kubota Y,
Watanabe H. Klinefelter syndrome
associated with unilateral crytorchidism
and chordee with hypospadias. Urol Int
1992; 48; 428-429.
- Dada R, Gupta N P, Kucheria K.
Spermatogenic Alterations in Men with
High Testiculo Epididymal Temperature.
Ind J of Hum Genetics 2002; 1(6):15-19.
- Bergere M, Wainer R, Nataf V, Bailly
M, Gombault M, Ville Y, Selva J.
Biopsied testis cells of four 47,XXY
patients: fluorescence in-situ
hybridization and ICSI results. Hum
Reprod 2002; 17(1): 32-37.
- Kucheria K, Jobanputra V, TalwarR,
AhmadME, Dada R, SivakumaranTA.
Prenatal and postnatal detection of
Aneuploidies using molecular
methods. Ind J Human Genetics
2002; 1(6),11-14.
- Kucheria K, Jobanputra V, TalwarR,
Ahmad ME, Dada R, TA
Sivakumaran. Human Molecular
Cytogenetics in Diagnosis, Prognosis
and Disease Management.
Teratogenesis, Carcinogenesis,
Mutagenesis (2003); 225-33
- Sparkes RS, Samec L, Kaplan SA,
Coulson WF. Concurrence of myotonic
dystrophy and XXY Klinefelter syndrome.
Clin Genet. (1973); 4(3):264-9.
- Foresta C, Galeazzi C, Bettella A, Marin
P, Rossat M, Garolla A, Ferlin A. Analysis
of meiosis in intratesticular germ cells
from subjects affected by classifical
Klinefelter’s Syndrome. The J Clin
Endocrinology and Metabolism. 1999;
84 (10): 3807-3810.
- Hasle H, Melleingaard A, Nielson J.
Cancer incidence in men with Klinefelter
syndrome. British J Cancer 1995; 71:
416-420.
- Peet J, Weaver DD, Vance GH.
49,XXXXY: a distinct phenotype. Three
new cases and review. J Med Genet
1998; 35(5): 420-424.
- Kleczkowska A, Fryns JP, Berghe HV. Xchromosome
polysomy in the male. Hum
Genet 1998; 80: 16-22.
- Linden MG, Bruce BG, Robinson A. Sex
chromosome tetrasomy and pentasomy.
Pediatrics 1995; 96 (4): 672-682.
- Kruse R, Gultenbach M, Schartmann B,
Schubert R, Ven DVH, Schund M,
Propping P. Genetic counselling in a
patient with XXY/XXXY/XY mosiac
Klinefilter syndrome : Estimate of sex
chromosome aberrations in sperm before
intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Fertility
and Sterility 1998; 69 (3): 482-486.
- Takeuchi Y, Myrata Y, Sintani J,
Masukawa H, Nakamura R, Oi K, Kato Y,
Niinomi M. Klinefelter’s syndrome
accompanied by mixed connective tissue
disease and diabetes mellitus. Intern Med
1999; 38(11): 875-81.
- Mulliez P, Darras A, Deschepper-
Crinquette MH, Crinquette J. Respiratory
disorders in Klinefelter’s syndrome.
Presse Med (1986); 15(14): 667.
- Sepulveda W, Ivankovic M, Be C,
Youlton R. Sex chromosome pentasomy
49, XXXXY presenting as cystic hygroma
at 16 weeks gestation. Prenatal Diagnosis
1999; 19: 257-259
- Estop AM, Munne S, Cieply KM. Meiotic
products of a Klinefelter 47,XXY male as
determined by sperm Fluorescence In Situ
Hybridization Analysis. Human
Reproduction 1998; 13: 124-127.
- Mark HFL, Feldman D, Sigman M:
Conventional and molecular cytogenetic
identification of variant Klinefelter
syndrome patient with a deleted X
chromosome. Pathology 1999; 67: 55-58.
- Bergmann M, Behre H M, Nieschlag E.
Serum FSH and testicular morphology in
male infertility. Clin Endocrinol 1994;
40:133-36.
Rima Dada, Rakesh Kumar, M E Ahmad, Rajeev Kumar, RS Sharma, NP Gupta, A Mitra, Gupta SK, K Kucheria
ISBN: 0973-516X
Rima Dada, MD, PhD (Associate Professor) and Rakesh Kumar (PhD Scholar) are from the
Department of Anatomy,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India.
M E Ahmad is PDF, CWRU, Cleveland, Ohio,USA
Rajeev Kumar is Associate Professor,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India
R S Sharma is Chief, ART Centre,
Army Research and Referral Hospital, New Delhi.
N P Gupta, M.S, M.Ch, FAMS, is Professor and Head, Department of Urology,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India.
A Mitra (Research Associate) and S K Gupta (Chief, Gamete Antigen Laboratory) are from the
National Institute of Immunology (NII), New Delhi.
K Kucheria, PhD, is Emeritus Medical Scientist,
All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi-110029, India
Corresponding Author: Dr Rima Dada, MD, PhD (Genetics), Associate Professor,
Lab for Molecular Reproduction and Genetics, Department of Anatomy, AIIMS, New Delhi 29
Email: [email protected]
Abstract:
Chromsomal abnormalities are common in infertile men with an incidence of 5.8% as compared to 0.5% in the general population. Klinefelter syndrome is the commonest genetic cause of hypogonadism and infertility. The incidence of sex chromosome abnormalities is 1 in 400 births which include 47,XXY; 47,XXX and 45,X karyotypes. The addition of more than one extra X or Y chromosome occurs rarely. Many studies consider variants as a part of Klinefelter syndrome (KFS), but these cases have additional phenotypic anomalies and should be considered as a distinct entity. The phenotypic defect in 47,XXY is well known but in variant cases with polysomy of X and Y leads to additional features like cardiovascular, skeletal, behavioural, language and expressive and speech disorders. For these clinical problems therapy is available and early diagnosis and early androgen therapy facilitates better management of these cases. There is a direct correlation between the number of additional sex chromosome and severity of the phenotype. Therefore, in order to analyze these variant cases in detail this study was planned.
Key words: Klinefelter syndrome (KFS), Mosaic, Variants, Hypogonadism
Introduction
Klinefelter’s syndrome is the most common genetic cause of male infertility, yet many cases remain undiagnosed because of substantial variation in clinical presentation. Early diagnosis and management with hormonal treatment can substantially improve the quality of life and prevent serious consequences. Sex chromosomal abnormalities occur in at least 1 in 400 births. One of the commonest chromosomal aneuploidy is Klinefelter Syndrome (KFS). KFS is the first human sex chromosomal abnormality to have been detected and is characterized by gynaecomastia, euchnoidism, small firm testes with hyalinization of seminiferous tubules, semeniferous tubular dysgenesis, androgen deficiency, hypergonadotrophic hypogonadism and azoospermia. This abnormality is the commonest cause of hypogonadsim and is associated with male infertility and cognitive defects. Its prevalence is 0.1% among infertile patients, up to 11% among the azoospermic, and 0.7% of oligozoospermics have 47,XXY chromosome complement. Of the 125 cases of male infertility referred to us, 44 were clinically diagnosed cases of KFS. We analyzed these 44 clinically suspected cases of KFS at the cytogenetic and molecular level using Fluorescent In situ Hybridisation (FISH) and found 14 cases with 47,XXY chromosome complement (KFS) and 23 cases with 46,XY/47,XXY karyotype. These cases were Klinefelter mosaics (KFM). Seven cases, which had additional cell lines, were classified as mosaic variants (KFV). These variant-cases showed additional clinical features, therefore they were studied in detail and their genotype was correlated with the phenotype.
Material and methods
Of the 125 cases of male infertility, 44 were clinically suspected cases of Klinefelter Syndrome and were referred to the infertility clinic of Urology and Endocrinology at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences. In each case a detailed clinical, reproductive and family history was taken and FSH, LH and testosterone levels were collected. Semen analysis was performed for assessing semen volume, pH, sperm count, viability, morphology, and motility as per the WHO guidelines (1999) (1). Testicular Fine Needle peripheral blood culture. Twenty-five well spread G-banded metaphases were karyotyped using Image Analysis System (Cytovision; Applied Imaging). In mosaic cases, 50 wellspread metaphases were analyzed. Fluorescent Aspiration Cytology (FNAC) was done whenever possible. Cytogenetic analysis was performed in each case by setting up In Situ Hybridization (FISH) was done following the standard protocol in 23 mosaic and 7 variant cases to identify any cryptic or low level mosaicism not detected cytogenetically. For FISH analysis, 200 interphase cells and 25 metaphase spreads were scored and the authors used CEP X and CEP Y fluorescent labeled probes. In the present paper, we discuss these cases with special emphasis on variant KF cases.
Klinefelter Syndrome
Of the 125 cases analysed cytogenetically 44 cases had KFS, of whom 14 had 47,XXY chromosome complement or were mosaics 46,XY/47,XXY-KFM (n=23) or variants KFV (n=7). The details of variant cases and comparison of KFV cases with the mosaic KFM and KFS cases have been tabulated (Tables 1 and 2).
Cases with 47,XXY Karyotype (KFS)
There were 14 cases with 47,XXY chromosomal complement, the mean age of whom was 25.6 years (range 20-35 years) and median height 170cm (range 158-188cm). Twelve cases had hypogonadism, two cases cryptorchidism and one case unilateral varicocele. Three of the 14 cases had micropenis while the rest had a normal phallus. Twelve cases exhibited poor development of secondary sexual characters; only two cases had well developed secondary sexual characters. Four cases had gynaecomastia. Seven cases had female habitus, while the other 7 had normal male habitus and were tall and thin. Of the 14 cases, 6 were mentally retarded while 8 cases had a normal intelligence quotient (IQ). Five cases showed behavioural abnormalities with severe temper tantrums and violent outbursts.
Three cases had speech abnormalities with difficulty in expressed speech. One case was impotent. All the fourteen cases were azoospermic (ie had complete absence of sperms in the semen). Thirteen cases had raised FSH levels while 1 case had decreased FSH level. In all the cases testosterone levels were low. Nine men were tall (>5 ft 8inch) and thin. Diabetes mellitus, anaemia and hepatitis B were found in 2 cases, one case had history of epileptic fits, while one case had asthma and recurrent episodes of upper respiratory infection. Testicular FNAC was done in 5 cases and showed ‘Sertoli Cell Only’ Type I syndrome (SCO Type I); in one case testicular biopsy showed hyalinization of the seminiferous tubules.
Table 1. Phenotypic Features in Men Mosaic Variants
Case No | Karyotype | Phenotype | FSH mIU/ml | LH mIU/ml | T (ng/ml) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Case 1 | 47,XXY/ 48,XXXXY/ 49,XXXYY |
SCO, BL Small, biopsy cluster of leydig cells only. MVP, sm penis, fat, hair on body present M19, P21, MR | 3.75 | 12 | 0.4 |
Case 2 | 46,XY(50%)/ 47,XXY/ 48,XXYY (20%) |
BL Small, Gyn Gr 3,Brest cancer small penis, no sec sex, low post. hair line, 5.8ft, M28, P30, speech abn, MR | 24 | 36 | 2.8 |
Case 3 | 46,XY(53%)/ 48,XXXY/ 49,XXXYY |
Thick BM, hyaline of ST (Biopsy), BL small testes, small penis, poor sec. sex, ASD, hypotonia, MR, no schooling d/t poor adj, temper, Speech abnormality, M33, P34 | 24 | 45 | 0.46 |
Case 4 | 47,XXY/ 48,XXYY/ 46,XX(20%)/ 47,XYY/ 50, XXXXYY |
Sm, Tall 6.2, obese, Coxavalga, Gyn, low post. hair line, broad nasal bridge, coarse facial features | 56.8 | 60 | ND |
Case 5 | 47,XXY (91%)/ 48,XXXY (3%)/ 48,XXYY (3%)/ 46,XY (3%) |
Hypogonadism, Atrophic, Prim. testicular failure, LoD, IQ less, poor in studies, MR, Gyn speech abn, 6 ft, M24,F30, micropenis, No sec sex | 56 | 68 | 0.2 |
Case 6 | 47,XXY/ 48,XXYY/ 46,XY(24%) |
Hypogonadism. Poor development of secondary sexual characters, very tall, small penis, speech abnormal,,Pulmonary stenosis | 44 | 38 | 0.4 |
Case 7 | 47,XXY/ 48,XXYY/ 48,XXXY |
Hypogonadism, poor dev. of seconadary sexual characters, slurred speech, congenital dislocation of hip, coarse facial features | 32 | 40 | 0.2 |
Key: T3, T4, TSH: Thyroid hormones; ST: Seminiferous tubules; Dev: Development; d/t: due to; LoD: Lack of development; Gyn: Gynaecomastia; SSC: Secondary sexual characters; Sm: Small gonads; M: Maternal age; P: Paternal age; B/L: Bilateral; Lt: Left; Rt: Right; MR: Mental retardation; Crypt: Cryptorchidism; ND: Not detected; Abn: Abnormal; Adj: Adjustment; URI: Upper respiratory tract infection; Desc: Descended; IQ: Intelligence Quotient; DM: Diabetes mellitus; Temp exp: Temperature exposure; H/o: History of; Prim: Primary; Hyalin: Hyalinization of seminiferous tubules
Table 2. Distribution of Clinical Abnormalities in KFS, Mosaic KF and Mosaic Variants Cases
S. No. | Features | KFS n-14 | KFM n-23 | KFV n-7 |
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Hypogonadism | 12 | 17 | 6 |
2 | Cryptorchidism | 2 | 5 | 0 |
3 | FNAC/ Biopsy-SCOI*/Hypospermatogenesis# |
5* |
1# |
2* |
4 | Poor development of secondary sexual characters | 12 | 12 | 6 |
5 | Small penis | 3 | 2 | 4 |
6 | Impotent | 1 | 0 | 0 |
7 | Female habitus | 7 | 1 | 0 |
8 | Gynaecomastia | 4 | 4 | 3 |
9 | ALL/Radiotherapy | 1 | 0 | 0 |
10 | Mental Retardation/Poor in studies | 6 | 1 | 4 |
11 | Temper tantrums/Violent behaviour | 5 | 1 | 1 |
12 | Azoospermic | 14 | 20 | 7 |
13 | Oligozoospermic/ OAT | 0 | 3 | 0 |
14 | Congenital heart disease (CHD) | 0 | 0 | 3 |
15 | Delayed milestones | 0 | 1 | 0 |
16 | Low posterior hair line | 0 | 0 | 2 |
17 | Speech abnormality | 3 | 0 | 5 |
18 | Varicocele | 1 | 0 | 0 |
19 | Recurrent URI | 1 | 1 | 0 |
20 | Very Tall ≥5-8 | 9 | 12 | 6 |
21 | Epileptic Fits | 1 | 0 | 0 |
22 | DM/Anaemia/Hepatitis B | 2 | 1 | 0 |
23 | High Temperature Exposure | 0 | 2 | 0 |
24 | Hypotonia | 0 | 0 | 1 |
25 | Skeletal abnormality | 0 | 0 | 2 |
26 | Normal FSH (1.2-5mIU/ml) | 0 | 1 | 1 |
27 | FSH raised | 13 | 21 | 6 |
28 | FSH low | 1 | 0 | 0 |
29 | Testosterone (2.7 –10.7ng/ml) | 0 | 0 | 1 |
30 | Testosterone low | 13 | 22 | 6 |
Mosaic Klinefelter Cases (KFM) (46,XY/47,XXY)
There were 23 mosaic cases of Klinefelter syndrome with a mean age of 25.5 years. Seventeen cases presented with hypogonadism and 5 cases had cryptorchidism. Eleven cases had well developed and 12 cases poorly developed secondary sexual characters. Twelve patients were tall (height > 5’8”). Of the 23 cases, only four cases had gynaecomastia. Two cases had micropenis; in the vast majority (21) of the cases the phallus size was normal. One case had mental retardation and was poor at studies; he was violent at times with frequent adjustment problem with his peers. Twenty mosaic Klinefelter cases were azoospermic with no sperms in the semen and 3 were oligozoospermic. Of the latter, two had a high percentage of morphologically abnormal sperms with impaired motility and were oligoastheno- teratozoospermic (OAT). These cases had, respectively, 90%, 75% and 70% normal cell line. One case was a diabetic. Two cases had occupational exposure to high temperature; one of them was azoospermic and one had OAT. Twenty one cases had raised FSH levels, while two cases had FSH in the normal range. Decreased testosterone levels were detected in all the twenty three cases. Testicular FNAC was available in one case with 46,XY(90%)/47,XXY chromosome complement and showed hypospermatogenesis.
Variant Klinefelter
There were 7 mosaic variant Klinefelter cases with a mean age of 30.4 years. Six of them presented with hypogonadism and six had poor development of secondary sexual characters. Four cases had micropenis while the phallus was of normal size in three cases. All the 7 cases were azoospermic. The FSH levels were raised in 6 cases but within normal limits in 1 case. The testosterone levels too were low in 6 cases and in the normal range in one patient. Six of the 7 cases were tall (>5 ft 8 in). Two cases had a low posterior hair line. Three cases had gynaecomastia (figure 1) and one case was diagnosed with breast cancer. Of the 7 cases, 3 had, respectively, congenital heart disease with mitral valve prolapse (MVP), atrial septal defect (ASD) and pulmonary stenosis with pulmonary hypertension. One of the seven cases had coxa vara and thus difficulty in walking and one case had congenital dislocation of the hip (CDH) at birth. FNAC biopsy showed ‘Sertoli Cell Only’ Type 1 (SCO type I) Syndrome in one case and the presence of Sertoli cells and clumps of Leydig cells in one. Details of all the KFV (Klinefelter variants) cases are given in Table1.
DISCUSSION
In the present study there were a total of 44 cases of Klinefelter syndrome, of whom 14 had 47,XXY chromosomal pattern (KFS), 23 were mosaic Klinefelter (KFM) (47,XXY/46,XY) and 7 were mosaic variants. All these cases were analysed at cytogenetic and molecular cytogenetic level using FISH. FISH confirmed the presence and proportion of mosaic cell lines and also identified cell lines not detected by routine cytogenetic methods. This cell line was detected in interphase cells and thus helps in a better understanding of the phenotype and correlations with the genotype. Okada et al., (1999)(2) studied 148 patients with sterility caused by Klinefelter Syndrome and found 140 men with Klinefelter Syndrome and 8 men to be mosaic Klinefelter. The overall percentage of Klinefelter cases in the present study was 35.2% (44/125). This was much higher than that previously reported (3%)(3).
This higher prevalence may be due to the fact that AIIMS is a national-level tertiary referral hospital and therefore a high number of suspected KFS cases are referred to us for cytogenetic and molecular analysis. KFS is a leading genetic cause of male infertility. In the present study prevalence of KFS among azoospermic cases was 24.10%. This was higher than 11% reported by Nemeth et al, (2002)(4) but was consistent with the findings of Tournaye et al.,(1996) (5) who reported an incidence of 15-22% in azoospermic men. Okada et al (1999) reported a prevalence of 70.4% in azoospermics and De Braekleer and Dao in (1991)(6) a value of 10%. We found an incidence of 12.5% KFS among the oligozoospermic cases, which is much higher than that reported earlier (0.7%) by Nemeth et al, (2002)(4). This high percentage may be explained by the small number of cases oligozoospermia in our study. Although gynaecomastia has been reported previously in 50% of patients (Tournaye et al., 1996) (5) it was found in only 25% of our cases. One case with gynaecomastia had breast cancer. The incidence of breast cancer is increased by 50% in men with KFS. Median height and weight indicated that the patients were slightly taller and thinner than the average cytogenetically normal men of the same age. These findings are similar to those of Okada et al (1999) (2). Over 80% of our patients had small testes, 7 men had cryptorchidism of which 5 were mosaics (46,XY/47,XXY). Saragawa et al (1992) (7) reported an association between KFS and hypospadias and cryptorchidism. In the present study none of the KFS or KFM cases had hypospadias but seven cases had cryptorchidism. Nine cases had normal testis and 35 cases (79.8%) had small testis. These findings are slightly lower than those reported by Tournaye etal.,(1996) (5) , who reported small testes in 95% of the affected men. The mean age of the Klinefelter patients was 27.1 years in the present study which was lower than 32 years found by Okada et al (2). This may be because of an early age at marriage in India as compared to that in Japan as a result of which the cases report with infertility at an earlier age in India.
Semen analysis revealed azoospermia in all the 14 cases of KFS, 20 cases of mosaic Klinefelter and 7 mosaic variants. Three mosaic cases with 30%, 15% and 10% 47,XXY cell line showed oligozoospermia. One of the mosaic cases worked in a rubber preparation factory and was exposed to high temperature which might have led to a high percentage of sperms with morphological abnormalities and impaired motility.(8) Testicular fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) showed hypospermatogenesis in this case. Though KFS is associated with a testicular phenotype of hyalinization of seminiferous tubules and semeniferous tubular dysgenesis this case showed hypospermatogenesis. This may be due to the presence of 90% normal cell line, 46,XY.
Though KFS is associated with azoospermia, recent studies (5,9) have reported spermatogenesis in mosaic cases. Two cases showed OAT though one of them had no exposure to high temperature. Okada et al., (1999) (2) also reported a high percentage of sperms with morphological abnormalities especially round and elongated spermatids in KFS subjects. In the present study, there were majority of sperms with amorphous head (22%), coiled tail (38%), and tapered head (15%).
Pubic hair distribution and euchnoid habitus was seen in 8 of the 44 cases. Okada et al (1999) (2) reported euchnoid habitus and female pattern of hair distribution in one third of the studied cases. Half of the patients in their study had low testosterone concentrations with elevated gonadotrophins while 50% had normal concentrations of testosterone. In the present study, however, we found low testosterone levels in the majority (93.2%) of cases; normal testosterone level was found only in one case. Of the 44 cases, gonadotrophins (FSH and LH) were elevated in 40 (90.9%) of cases, low in one case and within the normal range in three cases.
Two mosaic variants had low posterior hair line which has not been reported earlier in KF cases. The percentage of mosaicism detected by G banding and FISH was almost identical after scoring 200 interphase cells and 25 metaphase spreads. In one case FISH detected an additional cell line of 50,XXXXYY which was not detected cytogenetically. Thus FISH helps in detection of cryptic and low level mosaicism and is an important adjunct to conventional cytogenetics. FISH is a highly sensitive, efficient, accurate and reproducible technique that can be used independently for screening of aneuploidies. (10,11)
Azoospermia is not a consistent feature of KFS. Beregere et al in 2002 (9) found that 47,XXY subjects showed germinal aplasia while 46,XY/47,XXY mosaics focally showed spermatogenesis but Tournaye et al (1996) (5) found foci of spermatogenesis in some 47,XXY cases. Four out of 8 47,XXY subjects showing spermatogenesis were reported by Bergere et al (2002)(9). In the present study, 3 mosaic cases had oligoasthenoteratozoospermia and 1 case showed hypospermatogenesis. But two cases had high percentage (64% and 83%) of sperms with abnormal morphology and impaired motility and one case had oligozoospermia.
Sparkes et al., (1973) (12) and Foresta et al., (1999) (13) also reported a number of cases of KFS who had succeeded in fathering a child before the era of Assisted Reproduction. One case with 47,XXY chromosome complement had acute lymphocytic leukemia (ALL). Patients with KFS are known to be at an increased risk of malignant tumours(14) . Three variant mosaic cases, respectively, had congenital heart disease with mitral valve prolapse (MVP), atrial septal defect (ASD) and pulmonary stenosis with pulmonary arterial hypertension. Congenital heart defects have been reported in mosaic variant Klinefelter cases in earlier studies (15). These cardiovascular anomalies were not observed in KFS or KFM cases but three Klinefelter variants had cardiovascular anomalies. The presence of 48,XXYY and 49,XXXYY cell line probably led to the development of this cardiovascular defect. Studies have found that the greater the aneuploidy the more severe is the clinical manifestation of the disorder (16) . One KFS case had a history of epileptic fits since birth. Earlier tonic clonic seizures and epileptiform electroencephalograms (EEGs) were reported in 12 cases of KFS (16). Neurological deficit and seizures have also been reported by Tournaye etal.,(1996) (5) in KFS cases.
Twenty five percent (11/44) cases were found to have a low IQ in the present study, 17% also had behavioural problems and had violent temper outbursts. A higher risk of learning disabilities, cognitive deficit, and behavioural and psychiatric disorders exist in KFS, mosaics and mosaic variants. Linden et al., (1995) (17) and Kruse et al.,(1998) (18) reported that mental capability diminishes directly with the number of extra X chromosomes and IQ reduction of 15 to 16 points occurs with addition of each extra X chromosome.
One case with KFS and 3 variant mosaics had slurred speech and difficulty in expressive language. Linden et al., (1995) (17) concluded that language is also directly affected by the number of extra X chromosomes. Expressive and receptive language are both severely affected in men with extra X chromosome and this may lead to violent temper outbursts (16,17) . One variant mosaic was found to have hypotonia. Low muscle tone and muscular incoordination has been previously reported by Linden et al.,(1995) (17) who found that coordination is affected by extra genetic material. One mosaic variant case had coxa valga since birth and another variant case had congenital dislocation of hip (CDH). Skeletal anomalies like radioulnar synostosis, coxa valga and vara have been reported previously in KFV (15,17).
In addition there were 2 cases, one KFM and one KFS case with diabetes mellitus and one case with hepatitis B also had KFS. Two cases, one KFM and one KFS, had recurrent episodes of upper respiratory tract infection and asthma. Takeuchi et al., (1999) (19) reported a case of KFS with mixed connective tissue disease and diabetes mellitus. Mulliez et al., (1986) (20) reported respiratory disorders in 47,XXY subjects.
The pentasomy (49,XXXYY) and tetrasomy (48,XXYY) are two of the rarest sex chromosome defects occurring with an estimated incidence of 1 in 85,000 and 1 in 50,000 male births respectively.(21) In the curent study we had 7 variant cases and these cases had additional phenotypic features, cardiovascular and skeletal abnormalities, and severe mental retardation. Sex chromosomal polysomy is associated with pre- and postnatal growth deficiency, severe mental retardation, hypogenitalism, and skeletal, facial and cardiovascular anomalies. Linden et al (1995) (17) suggested that polysomy X and Y may lead to cognitive and behavioural problems which, in turn, might affect somatic development. The addition of a single X to an XY karyotype results in semeniferous tubule dysgenesis. Additional X and Y chromosome result not only in infertility but also in hypoplastic and malformed external genitalia. Three mosaic KF cases in our study had oligozoospermia. The presence of germ cells could probably be because of the normal cell line being the major cell line in these cases. Estop et al ( 1998)(22) and Foresta et al (1999)(13) suggested that in mosiac KF cases, germ cells may achieve meiosis and may produce mature spermatozoa. Accordingly, such cases from our study were made aware of the Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART) and were counselled to go in for case they opted for ART. All the variant cases had strikingly elevated gonadotrophins indicating markedly severe testicular damage due to the presence of extra genetic material and all were azoopsermic.
One of the cases (Case 2) presented with marked gynaecomastia. KF cases with gynaecomastia have been reported to have an increased risk of breast cancer (23).
One KFV case (Case 3) had a relatively milder phenotype with no cardiovascular or skeletal abnormality. The lesser severity of manifestation could be due to the presence of normal cell line compared to a male with pure polysomy X or Y and relatively few clinical manifestation. But the patient had an aggressive disposition with a low IQ. Abnormal behaviours and temper tantrums have been reported in sex chromosomal aneuploides in early studies (17).
A direct correlation between testicular function and FSH level is well established(24). The increase in FSH levels is a reliable indicator of testicular damage. However testicular FNAC of Case 1 showed Sertoli Cell Only Syndrome Type I indicating severe testicular damage although FSH and LH levels were within the normal range. The present finding stresses on the need of FNAC in such cases.
The present study highlights substantial variability in variant cases due to genetic heterogeneity. Molecular cytogenetic analysis also aids in a better understanding of the genotype-phenotype correlation by identifying cell lines not identified cytogenetically. Generalization of these mosaic cases is not possible and they should not be confused with classical KFS cases with 47,XXY karyotype. Detailed clinical, genetic evaluation should be undertaken and genetic counseling offered with early treatment to get better results by androgen therapy and psychological help.
Our study suggests that a larger number of cases needs to be analysed at both cytogenetic and molecular level to be able to appreciate the variability of phenotype and its correlations with the genotype. That will facilitate provision of suitable genetic counseling, early treatment, and better management of such cases.
Acknowledgements:
Authors thank the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) for the financial support.
REFERENCES
- World Health Organization. Laboratory Manual for the Examination of Human Semen and Sperm Cervical Mucus Interaction. 3rd edition. Cambridge University Press, Melbourne, Australia 1999.
- Okado H, Fujioka H, Tatsumi N, Kanzaki M, Okuda Y, Fujisawa M, Hazama M, Matsumoto O, Gohji K, Arakawa S, Kamidono S. Klinefelter’s syndrome in the male infertility clinic. Human Reprod 1999; 14 (4): 946-952
- Van Assche E, Bonduelle M, Tournaye H, Joris H, Verheyen G, Devroey P, Van Steirteghem. Cytogenetics of infertile men. Hum Reprod 1996; 11 (4): 1-24.
- Nemeth AH, Gallen IW, Crocker M, Levy E, Maher E. Klinefelter-like phenotype and primary infertility in a male with a paracentric Xq inversion. J Med Genetics 2002; 39(6): 28.
- Tournaye H, Staessen C, Liebars I, Van Assche E, Devroey P, Bonduelle M, Van Steirteghem A. Testicular sperm recovery in nine 47, XXY Klinefelter patients. Hum Reprod 1996;11: 1644-49.
- De Braekeleer M, Dao TN. Cytogenetic studies in male infertility: a review. Hum Reprod 1991; 6(2): 245-250.
- Sasagawa I, Nakada T, Hashimoto T, Ishigooka M, adachi Y, Kubota Y, Watanabe H. Klinefelter syndrome associated with unilateral crytorchidism and chordee with hypospadias. Urol Int 1992; 48; 428-429.
- Dada R, Gupta N P, Kucheria K. Spermatogenic Alterations in Men with High Testiculo Epididymal Temperature. Ind J of Hum Genetics 2002; 1(6):15-19.
- Bergere M, Wainer R, Nataf V, Bailly M, Gombault M, Ville Y, Selva J. Biopsied testis cells of four 47,XXY patients: fluorescence in-situ hybridization and ICSI results. Hum Reprod 2002; 17(1): 32-37.
- Kucheria K, Jobanputra V, TalwarR, AhmadME, Dada R, SivakumaranTA. Prenatal and postnatal detection of Aneuploidies using molecular methods. Ind J Human Genetics 2002; 1(6),11-14.
- Kucheria K, Jobanputra V, TalwarR, Ahmad ME, Dada R, TA Sivakumaran. Human Molecular Cytogenetics in Diagnosis, Prognosis and Disease Management. Teratogenesis, Carcinogenesis, Mutagenesis (2003); 225-33
- Sparkes RS, Samec L, Kaplan SA, Coulson WF. Concurrence of myotonic dystrophy and XXY Klinefelter syndrome. Clin Genet. (1973); 4(3):264-9.
- Foresta C, Galeazzi C, Bettella A, Marin P, Rossat M, Garolla A, Ferlin A. Analysis of meiosis in intratesticular germ cells from subjects affected by classifical Klinefelter’s Syndrome. The J Clin Endocrinology and Metabolism. 1999; 84 (10): 3807-3810.
- Hasle H, Melleingaard A, Nielson J. Cancer incidence in men with Klinefelter syndrome. British J Cancer 1995; 71: 416-420.
- Peet J, Weaver DD, Vance GH. 49,XXXXY: a distinct phenotype. Three new cases and review. J Med Genet 1998; 35(5): 420-424.
- Kleczkowska A, Fryns JP, Berghe HV. Xchromosome polysomy in the male. Hum Genet 1998; 80: 16-22.
- Linden MG, Bruce BG, Robinson A. Sex chromosome tetrasomy and pentasomy. Pediatrics 1995; 96 (4): 672-682.
- Kruse R, Gultenbach M, Schartmann B, Schubert R, Ven DVH, Schund M, Propping P. Genetic counselling in a patient with XXY/XXXY/XY mosiac Klinefilter syndrome : Estimate of sex chromosome aberrations in sperm before intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Fertility and Sterility 1998; 69 (3): 482-486.
- Takeuchi Y, Myrata Y, Sintani J, Masukawa H, Nakamura R, Oi K, Kato Y, Niinomi M. Klinefelter’s syndrome accompanied by mixed connective tissue disease and diabetes mellitus. Intern Med 1999; 38(11): 875-81.
- Mulliez P, Darras A, Deschepper- Crinquette MH, Crinquette J. Respiratory disorders in Klinefelter’s syndrome. Presse Med (1986); 15(14): 667.
- Sepulveda W, Ivankovic M, Be C, Youlton R. Sex chromosome pentasomy 49, XXXXY presenting as cystic hygroma at 16 weeks gestation. Prenatal Diagnosis 1999; 19: 257-259
- Estop AM, Munne S, Cieply KM. Meiotic products of a Klinefelter 47,XXY male as determined by sperm Fluorescence In Situ Hybridization Analysis. Human Reproduction 1998; 13: 124-127.
- Mark HFL, Feldman D, Sigman M: Conventional and molecular cytogenetic identification of variant Klinefelter syndrome patient with a deleted X chromosome. Pathology 1999; 67: 55-58.
- Bergmann M, Behre H M, Nieschlag E. Serum FSH and testicular morphology in male infertility. Clin Endocrinol 1994; 40:133-36.